Some comic-book stories end with a final issue.

Others simply stop.

Creators leave, publishers change direction, deadlines collapse, and once-promising narratives disappear into filing cabinets, legal limbo or the long silence between solicitations.

Sometimes the abandoned story stays dead.

Sometimes it rises from the Longbox Morgue.

Advertisement

The cover of Batman: The Widening Gyre #6 says “6 of 6.” In a back-issue bin, that looks like a guarantee. Find the other five, put them in order, and you’ve got the whole story. But when DC announced the series in May 2009, Kevin Smith described a twelve-issue Batman story divided into two books. The sixth issue was supposed to be the one you put down for six months. Sixteen years later, it’s still the last one you can buy.

Smith and penciller Walt Flanagan had already worked together on Batman: Cacophony. For their return to Gotham, with Art Thibert inking Flanagan’s pencils, Smith told Entertainment Weekly that he’d built a half-year break into the schedule to head off the lateness he was known for. All six scripts for the first volume were already done when the project went public, as was the art for issue #1. Readers were being asked to wait between volumes, and Smith had given them a reason to believe the second one would arrive on schedule.

Readers wound up doing some of that waiting inside the first volume. DC lists March 10, 2010, as the release date for issue #5 and July 28 for issue #6. Anyone following the series month to month had already gone more than four months without a new issue by the time the planned break began.

By December, DC was promoting the hardcover, and Smith called The Widening Gyre his favorite comic-book story he’d written. A reader picking up the collection could get through all six issues in an evening and land in the same place as the reader who’d been buying them off the rack. The hardcover collected every issue of the first volume. It also preserved the exact moment the story stopped.

The People Bruce Lets In

Silver St. Cloud had already figured out Bruce Wayne’s secret more than thirty years before Kevin Smith brought her back. In Steve Englehart and Marshall Rogers’ run on Detective Comics, Silver could see Bruce in the man fighting Deadshot even with most of his face covered. Knowing his identity made their relationship harder to sustain. When Silver returned in The Widening Gyre, she knew what she was coming back to, and Bruce had reason to believe that this time she meant to stay.

Smith and Walt Flanagan give the two of them somewhere to find out. On Silver’s private island, Bruce can spend a day with her and leave Gotham to itself for a few hours. The island scenes earn their place through the repetition. Bruce keeps coming back, and what begins as a reunion starts to look like a life he could actually lead. For Silver, who once walked away from that life, there’s something at stake in each return to Gotham. Every time Bruce leaves the island, she knows what he’s going back to.

Meanwhile, Batman meets Baphomet because he needs help. Poison Ivy has turned Arkham Asylum into an overgrown fortress, and Etrigan the Demon is getting the better of Batman when a stranger in a goat mask intervenes. The stranger disappears once the fight is over. He turns up again on another case, and eventually gives Batman a name. By then, helping Batman has become something he does often enough for Batman to count on it.

Advertisement

Batman does make an effort to find out who’s under the mask. In issue #5, he follows Baphomet home. The timing matters. By then, Bruce has already spent several issues growing comfortable with the arrangement. Baphomet’s habit of appearing when Batman needs him has answered the immediate question of whether he can handle himself in a fight. It leaves Bruce with a much harder question about the man who keeps showing up.

The Last Page of Issue #6

Spoilers for the final issue follow.

DC billed The Widening Gyre #6 as the extra-sized finale to volume one. That distinction mattered in July 2010. The creators had a second volume in the plan, and DC’s solicitation warned readers to expect a betrayal. Under those circumstances, ending the issue with Bruce Wayne’s life coming apart in the Batcave was a perfectly reasonable way to send readers into a six-month break.

Bruce has proposed to Silver by the time he brings Baphomet into the cave. He’s ready to show his new ally who he is and introduce him to the woman he plans to marry. Then Bruce sets down his utility belt and hears the sound it made repeated behind him. Smith has given Batman a false name and a mask to puzzle over for most of the series. The sound is what finally gives the man away. Baphomet is Onomatopoeia, the killer Smith brought into Batman’s orbit in Cacophony.

Readers who remembered Cacophony could recognize Onomatopoeia’s habit of imitating the sounds around him. By the time Bruce turns around, the man he brought home has a blade at Silver’s throat. Onomatopoeia cuts her, and the issue ends there.

The immediate question is whether Silver survives. The last page gives readers the wound and leaves everything that follows outside the issue. Bruce has to get to Silver, and the man who cut her is still in the cave with them. Even an answer about her survival would leave the rest of Bruce’s predicament intact. Onomatopoeia knows who Batman is, where he lives, and how he got past his defenses. Bruce showed him himself.

It’s easy to spend the intervening years arguing over whether Batman would ever make that mistake. Marcus Helminiak made that case in a 2025 retrospective for ComicBook.com, pointing out how little Bruce learns about Baphomet before extending him so much trust. There’s a related question the second volume could have answered. How would Bruce live with a decision he made at a moment when trusting someone finally seemed to be working for him? He’d taken a chance on a future with Silver, and she’d taken one on him. The last page gives her no say in what becomes of it.

The Sequel That Got a Name

In October 2012, Kevin Smith showed readers something they’d been waiting more than two years to see. Walt Flanagan had drawn a splash page for the first issue of the continuation, featuring Batman and Onomatopoeia. Smith shared it alongside a title and a release window. The next comic would be Batman: Bellicosity, and he was aiming for summer 2013. He presented it as the conclusion of the Batman story he and Flanagan had started in Cacophony and carried through The Widening Gyre. The villain in the Batcave was still the villain they intended to follow.

Advertisement

By then, Smith and Flanagan were also working on AMC’s Comic Book Men, the reality series centered on Smith’s comic shop, where Flanagan was the manager. A later ComicBook.com retrospective cited the show as a factor in the delay. Summer 2013 passed without a first issue.

At the Comic Book Men panel at New York Comic Con in 2016, Smith said Jim Lee had asked them when they were going to finish the book. Their story had begun before DC’s New 52 relaunch, and Smith said DC had given them latitude to decide how to proceed. He told the audience they had three issues, without specifying how much of the scripting or artwork was complete. Flanagan had suggested taking a cue from the Swamp Thing story that sends its hero to Hell, and Smith floated the possibility of twelve issues. By then, even the shape of the continuation was open for discussion.

The public record gets us as far as a title, a page of art, a missed release window, and a creator saying there were three issues in some form. DC’s catalog still lists the six published chapters and their collected editions, and ComicBook.com reported in 2025 that Bellicosity remained unreleased. For readers, that leaves Silver St. Cloud’s fate exactly where Flanagan drew it in 2010. After all the talk about what the next series might become, the first thing readers needed from it was one more page in the Batcave.

That brings us back to the copy in the longbox with “6 of 6” printed in the corner. You can find all six issues, bag and board them, and file them in order. By a collector’s reckoning, you have a complete set. Open the last one and Bruce Wayne is still turning around.